Book review –
Prema-gopāla
Goswāmī, page 9 –
Question –
In Bhakti-Rasamrta-Sindhu 1.2.5 Śṛila Rūpa Goswāmīpāda says that there are 2 types of sādhana - vaidhi and rāgānugā. They are described as parallel practices from the beginning. Chanting harināma, chanting the dīkṣā mantras, meditating on the līlās, doing pūjā, serving the deities, are also done in rāgānugā bhakti. Bhakti-Rasamrta-Sindhu describes vaidhi bhakti in verses 1.2.6-269 and rāgānugā bhakti in 1.2.270-306. Then Śṛila Rūpa Goswāmīpāda says -
sravanotkirtanadini
vaidha-bhakty-uditani tu
yany
angani ca tany atra vijneyani manīsibhih 1.2.296 ||
Prema-gopāla Goswāmī page 9 -
So service which is performed internally, by the mind,
is bhajana. Before that, it is vaidhī bhakti. Then why do vaidhī bhakti?
Because it establishes the foundation for entering rāgānugā bhakti.
Question
–
smaranam
is also an item of vaidhi bhakti. Śrī Prahlāda delineates vaidhi bhakti in
Śrīmad-bhāgavat 7.5.23 – śravaṇaṁ kīrtanaṁ viṣṇoḥ smaraṇam.
Prema-gopāla
Goswāmī page 9 –
Question
–
Yet,
I do not know any record of Śrīla Raghunātha dāsa Goswāmīpāda, rāgānugā ācārya
par excellence, offering his Giridhārī to his disciples - he did not even have
disciples. But it is true that Mahāprabhu taught him a simple type of arcanā
for rāgānugā bhakti in Caitanya Caritāmṛta, Antya-līlā chapter 6. Surely not with
the great pomp and ritual like in many Vaiṣṇava temples.
Prema-gopāla
Goswāmī, page 10 -
Question
–
This
also is true but I do not know any record that Sanātana Gosvāmīpāda gave up Madanmohan
altogether.
Prema-gopāla
Goswāmī, page 11 -
When will the desire to have the mood of Rādhā's
maidservants appear? Only after āsakti.
Question
–
Is
there any evidence in śāstra for this
statement? Without being on the āsakti
stage we have been desiring manjari bhāva
for the past 40 years. rāgānugā is a sādhana, not a siddhi.
Prema-gopāla Goswāmī -
I have asked Premgopāl Gosvāmī to clarify, “Are you
saying we should follow guru's instructions irrespective of śāstra?” He
replied, “No, not irrespective of śāstra. We must trust that sad guru would never
advice or order anything contrary to the scriptures. So, everything will be
under the guidance of śāstra. What I said is more about the disciples'
dedication and faith in guru. We must have such faith and dedication for guru
that his instructions will be the last word for us. We shouldn’t judge if those
instructions are from śāstra or not.”
Advaitadās
-
This
is excellent.
Prema-gopāla Goswāmī, page 12 –
It may be fraternal mood, sakhya bhāva, then I must
follow Śrīdāma or Sudāma. Or it may appear in my heart as, “Oh! My Gopāljī,”
vātsalya bhāva, then one will follow Nanda Bābā and Mā Yaśodā. And when
attachment appears for Yugala Kiśora, we must follow the Vraja gopīs headed by
Śrīmatī Rādhārāṇī.
Question
–
Caitanya
Caritāmṛta (Adi 1.4) clearly says –
anarpita-carīṁ
cirāt karuṇayāvatīrṇaḥ kalau
samarpayitum
unnatojjvala-rasāṁ sva-bhakti-śriyam
hariḥ puraṭa-sundara-dyuti-kadamba-sandīpitaḥ
sadā hṛdaya-kandare
sphuratu vaḥ śacī-nandanaḥ
"May the Supreme Lord Hari, who is known as the son of Śrīmatī
Śacī-devī, be transcendentally situated in the innermost chambers of your
heart. Resplendent with the radiance of molten gold, He has appeared in the Age
of Kali by His causeless mercy to bestow what no avatāra has ever offered
before: the most sublime and radiant mellow of devotion, the rasa of amorous love."
Since this is the opening verse of Caitanya Caritāmṛta it is clear that
Śrī Caitanya Mahāprabhu’s great gift is only gopī bhāva.
Prema-gopāla
Goswāmī, page 24 -
But why call these mañjarīs ‘nitya-sakhīs’? Because
here ‘nitya’ means something else: It means they are always with Śrīmatī
Rādhārāṇī, just like Her shadow. They are with Her every single moment.
Advaitadās
-
This
is excellent.
Prema-gopāla
Goswāmī, page 26 -
They are very close to Her heart. That’s why they are
known as prāṇa-sakhīs. They are like the prāṇa [life-air] of Śrīmatī Rādhārāṇī.
It is very nicely said, sakhīnāṁ saṅginī-rūpām ātmānaṁ vāsanā-mayīm. They are
vāsanā, they always want to do some sevā for Śrīmatī Rādhārāṇī. They are always
looking for service: What to do? What can I do? How can I serve?
Advaitadās
-
This
is excellent.
Prema-gopāla Goswāmī, page 30 -
Or if we talk about Maṇi Mañjarī, “Oh, Maṇi Mañjarī
knows how to make very beautiful garlands.” That is her special quality. Not
that, “Maṇi Mañjarī's dress is very light, very beautiful.” No. That is not the
special quality of a mañjarī. They are expert in decorating themselves very
nicely, but that is not their distinctive quality. Their special quality is
that they can dress and decorate Śrīmatī Rādhārāṇī very expertly.”
Advaitadās
-
This
is an interesting and important point.
Prema-gopāla Goswāmī, page 33 -
One tadīyāta bhakta is explaining, expressing his mood
of sevā to one rasika bhakta, madīyāta bhakta – who is feeling, “Kṛṣṇa is mine!
Therefore, I have to take care of Him. I have to accept full responsibility for
Kṛṣṇa. No one is there to take care of Him, I have to do that. This is my duty
and my responsibility. It is my responsibility to offer food to Kṛṣṇa, to dress
Him, to put Him to sleep, etc. How then can I disturb Him with my problems? My
material problems?”
Advaitadās
– This is what our Guru Sādhu Bābā taught us too – “Don’t bother Madangopāl
with your problems. Pray to guru for that. Let Rādhā-Madangopāl enjoy in
peace.”
Question –
Prema-gopāla Goswāmī speaks a lot about manjaris getting that same pleasure a hundred times
more than Śrīmatī Rādhārāṇī, but is this practically possible? Caitanya Caritāmṛta
says that, but it's a glorification, an emotional statement. Rādhā has the
highest bhāva – rādhikā sarvathādhikā (Ujjvala Nīlamaṇi). Can we multiply the Unlimited?
Prema-gopāla Goswāmī, page 35 -
Sometimes my senior mañjarī would say, 'Okay, go to
the garden and bring some flowers. Make very beautiful garland and offer it to
Śrīmatī Rādhārāṇī. She will then offer it to Kṛṣṇa.' I followed her instruction
and the path to the garden was passing by that rahasya nikuñja. When I was
passing by that rahasya nikuñja, my mind was overcome by curiosity. 'Let me
just see what are They doing?' I started to watch Them through the lattice
window and became absorbed in the beautiful, intimate pastime of Śyāmasundara
and Kiśorījī. It was very beautiful, very sweet, and I became totally absorbed,
so I forgot about my assigned sevā.”
Question
–
This
is an interesting topic. The manjari forgets her sevā due to āveśa. I cannot
recall if there an instance of this in the ācāryas’ writings?
Prema-gopāla Goswāmī, page 40 -
Perhaps to push me into starting my bhajana,
rāgānugā-bhajana, he will give me siddha-praṇālī, reveal my siddha svarūpa.
“Here, this is your mañjarī svarūpa.” However, it is still the case that if am
not properly following the path of bhajana, perfection will remain far away
from me. Our bhajana must be from our heart, not from our head, not by
intelligence – it must be by love.
Advaitadās – This is so true.
Prema-gopāla Goswāmī, page 43 -
One grantha samādhi was also there in Rādhā Dāmodara
temple, but some 16 years ago, they broke it open for reconstruction, and they
were surprised to find more than 15,000 manuscripts there. However, it turned
out that most of the manuscripts were not essential for us.
Question
-
It is
the first time we hear this story, but the point is well taken. There is no
need for reading so many books – Bhagavad-Gītā, Śrīmad Bhāgavat, Caitanya
Caritāmṛta, Stavāvalī, Rādhā-rasa-sudhānidhi are sufficient.
She loves them more than her sakhīs who have sama
snehādhika.
Question
–
This
is wrong. sama (equality) and adhika (superiority) conflict. The author
probably means just sama sneha, equal affection.
Prema-gopāla
Goswāmī, page 48 –
Advaitadās – This is also
interesting.
Prema-gopāla
Goswāmī, page 48 -
The mañjarīs experience whatever Rādhārāṇī experiences. Kṛṣṇa does not touch the mañjarīs, He touches Śrīmatī Rādhārāṇī. Still the mañjarīs experience Kṛṣṇa’s touch in their hearts and on their bodies…
Advaitadās – This is a point that every publisher or lecturer of Vilāpa Kusumānjali copies from Ānanda Gopāla Goswāmī. Ānanda Gopāla Goswāmī said –
শ্রীরাধার অধরের ক্ষত শ্রীরূপমঞ্জরীর অধরে প্রকাশ । শ্রীপ্রাণেশ্বরীর হৃদযের সহিত ইহাদের হৃদযের এতই তাদাত্ম্যা প্রাপ্ত ইহা দ্বারা অনুভব করা যায় ।
“The bites on Śrī
Rādhā’s lips are also manifest on Rūpa Mañjarī’s lips - the mañjarīs’ hearts
are so identical with Prāṇeśvarī’s heart that they also experience what She
experiences!”
Prema-gopāla
Goswāmī, page 51 –
Question
–
But how
will she keep the sakhis away without insulting them and violating the
etiquette? The sakhīs are senior to the manjaris, after all. They cannot just
tell them to go away or so?
Prema-gopāla
goswāmī page 51-52 -
Ānanda
Gopāla Goswāmī’s comment on Vilāpa-kusumānjali 1 –
তখন তুলসী ঐ কুঞ্জের বাহিরে কুঞ্জে পীঠ দিযে একখানি অপূর্ব মদন গান গাইতে আরম্ভ করিলেন । গানখানি পূর্বে স্বামিনীজী তুলসীকে নিভৃত গোবর্দ্ধন গোফায় গাইয়া শিখাইয়াছেন । যাহা সখীগণের নিকটেও প্রাণেশ্বরী শিখাইতে পারেন নাই । গানখানি কুঞ্জের অভ্যন্তরেই খেলিয়া বেড়ায়, কুঞ্জের বাহিরে যায় না ।
Śrī
Tulasī Mañjarī then starts singing an amorous song, which she had previously
learned from Svāminī in a solitary cave of Mount Govardhana, sitting outside of
the grove. Such songs Prāṇeśvarī cannot even teach Her intimate girlfriends!
The
song is sung here by Rūpa Manjari, not by Tulasī, but otherwise the līlā is the
same.
Prema-gopāla Goswāmī, page 42 -
Rūpa Manjarī is now speechless with surprise because she was not aware of that love bite on her lips.
Vilāpa-kusumānjali
1 commentary by Kiśora Gopāl Goswami, Ānanda Gopāl Goswāmī’s eldest son -
আত্মহারা রূপের কোন অনুসন্ধান নাই, একেবারে বিভোর ।
Śrī
Rūpa Mañjarī is beside herself of ecstasy, so she's not aware of these
bite-wounds on her own lips.................
Prema-gopāla
Goswāmī, page 52 -
Vilāpa-kusumānjali
verse 2, commentary by Kiśora Gopāl Goswami -
কুঞ্জে বিলাসের চরম পরিণতিতে আনন্দবৈবশ্য আসিয়া নাগরকে বিবশ করিয়া ফেলিয়াছে ।
During the climax of the kunja vilāsa Nāgara (Kṛṣṇa) is beside Himself of ecstasy. –
The same
word is used here, vivaśa.
Prema-gopāla Goswāmī, page 52 –
Vilāpa-kusumānjali
verse 1, commentary by Kiśora Gopāl Goswami –
আত্মহারা রূপের হঠাৎ মনে হইল, 'এমন মধুর যুগলবিলাস! হায়! তুলসী ত দেখল না! কোথায় সে? | তাহাকে আনিয়া দেখাইতে হইবে' । যেইমাত্র শ্রীরূপমঞ্জরীর তুলসীর কথা মনে জাগিল তিনি গবাক্ষ ছাড়িয়া তুলসীর অনুসন্ধানে আসিলেন ।
Then she suddenly thinks to herself: "Such a sweet love pastime of our beloved Pair! Aha! My sakhī Tulasī Mañjarī has not seen it! Alas, where is she? I should bring her here and show this to her!", so she promptly leaves the window and starts searching for Tulasī.
Prema-gopāla Goswāmī, page 57 -
Vilāpa-kusumānjali
verse 2, commentary by Kiśora Gopāl Goswami –
দ্বিতীয় শ্লোকে বিলাসের বিরামে বিবশ নাগরকে ফেলিয়া মদীয়তার অপূর্ব উন্মাদনায় স্বামিনীর কুঞ্জান্তরে সখীসমাজে সখীগণের সহিত মিলন ও হাস্য পরিহাস ।
Svāminī
abandons Her overwhelmed lover and proudly goes out of the kūñja into a
neighboring kuñja where She shares the relish of parihāsa rasa (transcendental
flavour of laughter and humour) with Her girlfriends…..”
Prema-gopāla Goswāmī, page 60 -
Vilāpa-kusumānjali
verse 2, commentary by Kiśora Gopāl Goswami –
এইভাবে পবন বাহিত প্রিয়ার অঙ্গগন্ধের ঘ্রাণ পাইয়া তাহার সহিত মিলিত হইবার জন্য যখন নাগর ব্যাকুল, তখন পথে পদ্মা, শৈব্যা প্রভৃতি চন্দ্রাবলীজীউর সখীগণ আসিয়া অবরোধ করায়,
Just
as the breeze, that carries Priyā’s bodily scent, makes Nāgara Kṛṣṇa eager to
meet with Rādhā, Candrāvalī’s girlfriends like Padmā and Śaibyā intercept Him
on the way.
Prema-gopāla Goswāmī, page 62 -
Vilāpa-kusumānjali
verse 2, commentary by Kiśora Gopāl Goswami –
শ্রীস্বামিনীজীউর সম্প্রতি হৃতাত্মা রসসাগর স্বরূপ শ্যামসুন্দরের নিকটে নাই । সেই অবস্থাটিকেই 'স্থলকমলিনি' এই সম্বোধনের দ্বারা প্রকাশ করিতেছেন । কারণ সাগরের মধ্যে যখন কমল তাঁর তখন 'স্থলকমল' না হযে, 'কমলই' নাম হয় । স্বামিনীজীউর সেই অবস্থাটি বোঝাবার জন্য তুলসী 'স্থলকমলিনী' শব্দের দ্বারা স্বামিনীজীকে সম্বোধন করিয়াছেন ।
The
fact that Svāminī is here addressed as 'land lotus', indicates that She is not
close to the Śyāma-ocean of rasa (the word ka-mala means water flower, but She's
named sthala-kamalinī, land lotus, here).
Prema-gopāla Goswāmī, page 72-73 -
vrajendra vasati stahle vividha ballabī saṅkule
tvam eva rati mañjarī pracura puṇya punjodayā
vilāsa-bhara vismṛta praṇayi mekhalā mārgaṇe
yad adya nija nāthayā vrajasi nāthitā kandaram
[Oh Rati Mañjarī! You are the most fortunate cowherd
damsel in the abode of the king of Vraja! When Your mistress, Śrī Rādhikā,
forgets Her beloved sash of bells due to absorption in Her love play, She asks
You to fetch it from the cave where She left it! (Vilāpa-kusumānjali 3)]
Advaitadas
-
In
various devotional books and manuals it is suggested that Śrīla Raghunātha Dāsa
Gosvāmī is Rati Mañjarī in Vraja līlā, but here Raghunātha dāsa Gosvāmī himself
states otherwise. There is a similar statement from him about this in his
Stavāvalī-
śrī
rūpa rati mañjaryor aṅghri sevaika gṛdhnunā
asaṅkhyenāpi
januṣā vraje vāso'stu me'niśam
“Let
me stay in Vraja for innumerable births, simply having the desire to serve the
lotus-feet of Śrī Rūpa and Śrī Rati Mañjarī!” (Prārthanāmṛta – 1)
If
Raghunātha dāsa Gosvāmī is himself Rati Mañjarī, why would he pray to himself
in these two verses? There is no precedent for this – nowhere it can be found
that Śrīla Rūpa Gosvāmī prays to Rūpa Mañjarī, and so on. One prays only to
superiors. In this case Śrīla Raghunātha dāsa Gosvāmī prays to Śrī Advaita
Ācārya, who is Rati Mañjarī in Kṛṣṇa līlā and his parama guru, the Guru of his Guru Śrī Yadunandana Ācārya, in Gaura-līlā. That is made even more clear by the
fact that next in his sequence of prayers is Śrī Yadunandana Ācārya, in verse
four.
Prema-gopāla Goswāmī, page 75-76 -
Śrīmatī Rādhārāṇī looked at the sakhīs and said, “Oh
sakhīs, try to make Kṛṣṇa happy.” So the sakhīs started to dance and sing to
celebrate the reunion of Śrī Rādhā-Govinda. Both of Them were seated in a very
nice place, and now the sakhīs wanted to dance with Śrīmatī Rādhārāṇī. They
invited Her, “Oh Rādhe, please come join us. All of us will perform our dancing
for Kṛṣṇa's pleasure.”
Kṛṣṇa said, “My dear sakhīs, now you should all take
some rest. Now, Śrīmatī should dance alone. Oh Rādhe, please dance.”…………….It
was going on sweetly but then something happened, something was missing, and
Śrīmatī Rādhārāṇī started to feel very shy.
During Her dancing, Śrīmatī Rādhārāṇī realized she
forgot her mekhalā [waist belt] in the kuñja, in that kandaram, that cave where
She was with Kṛṣṇa. Because of Her pride She forgot Her mekhalā.
Ānanda Gopāla Goswāmī Vilāpa-kusumānjali 3 –
প্রাণেশ্বরীর ইঙ্গিত পাইয়া সখীগণ সম্মুখস্থ প্রাঙ্গণে নৃত্য করিলেন, পরে সখীগণের ইচ্ছায় স্বামিনীজী নৃত্য করিতে আরম্ভ করিলেন । কটিতে মেখলা নাই, তাই নৃত্য জমিতেছে না । মেখলাটি কুঞ্জে ফেলিয়া আসিয়াছেন, সখীগণের সামনে বলিতে পারিতেছেন না, তাহারা পরিহাস ক|রিবে, তাই সখীগণের অলক্ষিতে রতিমঞ্জরীকে ইঙ্গিত করিলেন শ্রীরতিমঞ্জরীও দ্রুতগতিতে মেখলাটি আনিয়া অন্যের অলক্ষেতে নাচিতে নাচিতে যাইয়া মেখলাটি পরাইয়া দিলেন ।
On
Prāṇeśvarī’s indication the sakhīs dance on the courtyard in front of Them,
then later on the sakhīs’ request Svāminī also gets up to dance. But She had no
bells strapped around Her waist, so Her dancing did not resound. She had lost
these bells during Her love-meeting in the kunja, but She cannot reveal that to
Her girlfriends because they will make fun of Her, so She gives an unseen hint
to Śrī Rati Mañjari to fetch the bells from the kunja. Śrī Rati Mañjari quickly
runs to the kunja and, hangs the bells back on Svāminī’s waist without being
noticed by Her girlfriends, since she seems to be just joining in the dance.
Prema-gopāla Goswāmī, page 76 -
Once, Śrīmatī Rādhārāṇī was dancing while Kṛṣṇa was
playing the flute very nicely. Kṛṣṇa’s flute and Śrīmatī Rādhārāṇī’s caraṇa
nūpura, ankle-bells, were playing perfectly in rhythm together. The beat was
perfect. But suddenly, one ankle bell fell off from Śrīmatī Rādhārāṇī’s lotus
feet, so the rhythm was broken.
Ānanda Gopāla Goswāmī Vilāpa-kusumānjali verse 7
রাসনৃত্যে শ্রীকৃষ্ণ বাঁশী বাজাইতেছেন, স্বামিনীজীউ নৃত্য করিতেছেন । এক চরণের নূপুর খসিয়া গিয়াছে । বাঁশীর গান নূপুরের ধ্বনি সহিত খুব ঝমাট হইয়াছিল, এখন তাহার অভাব । শ্যামসুন্দর নিজ নৃত্য মাধুরী প্রকাশ করিয়া ঘুরাইয়া নিজ হাতে নূপুর পরাইয়া দিলেন । কেহ টের পাইল না ।
Once,
during the Rāsa-dance, Kṛṣṇa plays His flute and Svāminījī dances, when one of
Her anklebells falls off. The tinkling of those anklebells enhances the beauty
of Kṛṣṇa's flute song, but now it’s gone. Śyāma exposes the sweetness of His
own dancing and twirls around while at the same time placing the anklebells
back on Svāminī's feet - no one noticed!
Prema-gopāla
Goswāmī p.95
“Hey Rādhe,
maybe I’m not really qualified to serve You. Maybe I do not have the right
qualities to serve You. But she who offered me to Your lotus feet is very near
and dear to You.
Ānanda
Gopāla Goswāmī Vilāpa-kusumānjali verse 7
আমার অযোগ্যতা
থাকিতে পারে, কিন্তু যিনি আমাকে তোমার চরণে সমর্পণ করিয়া দিয়াছেন, তিনি ত তোমার যোগ্যা দাসী! | তাহার সমর্পিত জনকে কেন অঙ্গীকার করিবেন না?
I may
be unqualified, but he who has offered me to Your lotus-feet for Your maid
service is Your qualified maidservant. Why will You not accept someone who is
offered to him?
Prema-gopāla
Goswāmī p.97
After Rūpa Mañjarī arranged the meeting of Yugala in
the cave, she stayed outside singing a very romantic song to increase Their
love. She is just outside the kuñja. Tulasī Mañjarī also does this. By watching
Śrīmatī Rādhārāṇī from outside the kuñja, she can understand exactly what She
needs.
Ānanda
Gopāla Goswāmī Vilāpa-kusumānjali 35
কুঞ্জের বাহিরের দ্বারে পীঠ দিয়া কিঙ্করী গান করিতেছেন আনন্দমূর্চ্ছ নাগর শুনিয়া উদ্বুদ্ধ! । তুলসীর গানে নাগরের মূর্চ্ছা ভেঙ্গে গেল । বিলাস আরম্ভ হল ।
The maidservant sits with her back to the gate outside of the kunja and sings a song, thus causing Nāgara to awaken from His ecstatic swoon and the love-play to resume.
Prema-gopāla
Goswāmī p.98
Tulasī Mañjarī can be boldly talkative with Kṛṣṇa,
“Just see, You only know how to control the cows and play the flute. But Kṛṣṇa,
decorating Śrīmatī Rādhārāṇī, painting Her lotus feet, is not the same as
controlling the cows and playing the flute.
Ānanda
Gopāla Goswāmī Vilāpa-kusumānjali 16
শ্যামের পরাজয় হইয়াছে দেখিয়া বলিতেছেন - "ওহে! পাশা খেলিতে এস না! গরু চরাণোই ভাল, গরু চরাইলে গরুর মতোই বুদ্ধি হয়!" |
Seeing that Śyāma is
defeated the maidservant says: “O hey! Don’t come here to play dice! Better You
go out to herd the cows, cowherding gives you the brain of a cow!”
End
note - The publisher has unfortunately little knowledge of Sanskrit or Bengali.
The spelling of some words is terrible - rasika
jāna, tadīyāta bhakta, prema bikari, akila